Work Text:
It's no secret that Archie Andrews isn't the smartest kid in Riverdale, but everyone knows he has one of the biggest hearts. Which is how he ends up in Clifford and Penelope's manipulative grasps for the second time.
Archie knows what kind of people the Blossoms are—he experienced it first hand when they tried to bribe him into being a boyfriend for Cheryl, back when he'd agreed to fill in for Jason at the Maple Tapping Ceremony—and yet here he is again.
It had been Clifford that approached him first this time, man to man, to ask him to play Jason's role one more time, at a very important ceremony held by the Blossom board. He'd been upfront about it this time, just offering him cold hard cash instead of any shady deals to make him connections or thinly veiled threats, and because of that, Archie didn't turn him down immediately.
Twenty grand for one day, just to appear at some board meeting? It was too good to be true, but also too good to completely write off either.
His dad had advised against it, but then Cheryl stopped by and tugged at his heartstrings.
"Please, Archie," she'd begged him, her usually guarded eyes wide and pleading. "You haven't the faintest idea how important this ceremony is for me. JJ and I had been dreaming of it since we were preteens. It's my birthday and it's the most vital of Blossom traditions and I simply cannot do it on my own. I need you for this, Archie, please. I can't disappoint my family more than I already have. This is my last chance to prove my worth to them."
There was no way Archie could say no to a plea like that.
So now here Archie is, standing naked in the garden of Thornhill, in front of a sea of other pale redheads, listening to Clifford explain just what kind of mess Archie has gotten himself into this time.
"Good afternoon! As you all know, today marks the eve of my darling Cheryl's 18th birthday, which makes this the day of her Coming of Age Ceremony," Clifford's booming voice explains to his guests, even though they all seem to know what's going on. Archie's pretty sure he's the only one still in the dark. "I would like to thank you all for attending today's ceremony, to witness as my only daughter becomes not only a woman, but realizes her true purpose as a Blossom woman: bearing a child."
The crowd erupts in oohs and ahhs and Cheryl is beaming up at Clifford and Archie is just trying to process everything he just heard.
“What the fuck?” Archie mumbles to herself, leaning forward to try to catch Cheryl’s gaze on the other side of her father. But she’s too busy looking at her father to notice.
"Due to the tragic passing of our beloved son Jason, my wife and I had to find a suitable young man to take his place," the Blossom patriarch continues, gesturing towards the teens standing beside him. "As disappointing as it is that Cheryl cannot lose her virginity to or carry her brother's child, as has been Blossom tradition for many decades before her, Archibald Andrews—a stand up, hard working young man, with striking looks similar to our Jason's—is the next best thing. At least, considering an old man like myself isn't quite up for the task." There's a low rumbling of laughter from the crowd. "As the ceremony begins, I must remind you that there is to be no talking or recording of any kind, and everyone is to remain seated until the kids are finished." When nobody has any objections, Clifford steps back from between the two naked teens and walks to his wife’s side, and proudly declares, “Let the Coming of Age Ceremony commence!”
As her parents make their way to their front row seats, Cheryl gently takes Archie’s hand and guides him over to the day bed that’s been placed in the center of the garden. She squeezes his hand once and then crawls onto the bed, lying back and spreading her legs.
And oh, wow: that's Cheryl's pussy.
The bed is positioned so that only Archie gets the pleasure of the view, while the audience sees their profiles. So while they may not be able to see Cheryl’s cunt, they can definitely see Archie’s hard cock as he stands between her legs, not knowing what to do.
It may seem obvious, but like... Is he just supposed to stick it inside her now? Is he really going to do this?
"Come on then, Archie Andrews," Cheryl purrs, her eyes warm and open, just like her legs, and she curls her finger to beckon him forward and yep, looks like Archie is really going to do this, and not just because he can't seem to say no to the girl in front of him.
"This is crazy," he mumbles to her as he settles between her legs, trying to keep his eyes on her and ignore the many, many eyes on him.
Cheryl just smiles softly at him, reaching up to wrap her fingers around the back of his neck and scratch gently at the hair there. "Just breathe," she tells him. "Relax. I'm the one losing my virginity here."
"And getting pregnant?" Archie adds on in disbelief, still not quite processing that part of it all—he's been mostly focusing on the whole having sex in front of a bunch of people part.
"Hopefully," Cheryl sighs freely, batting her eyelashes at him. "It's Blossom tradition that once twins turn 18, the boy is conducted into the family business and the girl is to bear his child. I so did dream of this day with my JJ, of being with him in the most intimate way possible. Of carrying his child."
That's a lot to take in and Archie's brain is kind of already overloaded, so instead of thinking about it too much, he just nods and tries to give his friend a smile. Because as much as he knows Cheryl has always been desperate to please her parents, he can tell by the look on her face and the way she speaks that this is something she wants for herself. So he wants it for her too.
"Hey, I'll-I'll do my best for you, okay, Cheryl?" he promises, finally touching her by gently holding her round hips.
"I know you will," she says, her nails on his neck making him shiver. "You're special, Archie Andrews, almost as special as my JJ. So if not him, I'm so glad it's you." Archie finds her words sweet and kind and comforting, and it isn't until just now that he realises she's successfully been able to drown out the rest of the crowd, because it's felt like just them in their own little bubble for the past couple minutes. "Are you ready?"
But now it's impossible for him to ignore them all again. "I-I think so," he answers anyway, bending his knees to get to the right height to line his cock up with her entrance. "Tell me if you need me to stop."
"Please don't stop," Cheryl whimpers as Archie's cock slowly starts to enter her, the soft, pink lips of her virgin pussy parting for his thick shaft as he slips in, in, in.
Oh, that feels good.
Archie is hardly a virgin, not in any sense of the word, but as he slowly slips the length of his cock into Cheryl's untouched cunt until his thighs reach the edge of the bed, it doesn't feel like it ever has before.
She gasps as she's broken in, her pale body arching off the bed as all of Archie's cock settles snugly inside her, filling her all the way up.
Cheryl's pussy is so warm and tight around Archie's cock, and all the eyes watching them with rapt attention makes the rest of his naked body blush hot too, but he tries to look only at the girl in front of him as he slowly pulls out so he can push into her for a second time.
It's still as tight a fit, and judging by the look on her face, it's still a little painful for Cheryl, but she told him not to stop, so Archie doesn't. He's just slow and careful with his hips, pumping into the girl in long strokes until the muscles in her face relax a little, and in her cunt too.
It takes a while, but eventually Archie feels Cheryl loosen a little bit around him, the walls of her pussy slick and tight still but not quite as clenched. He can move through her easier now and pick up his pace a bit.
He doesn't fuck her the way he would if they were alone—the way he's fucked Miss Grundy and Veronica and even Betty, that time she put on a black wig and crawled in through his bedroom window in the middle of the night.
No, Archie keeps his thrusts long still, just a bit faster than before, and smoother, the arousal dripping from Cheryl making her insides feel like butter around his cock.
She's mewling now, little whimpers and sighs escaping her done up red lips as Archie pumps into her faster, and for a fleeting moment he wonders if she's imagining it's Jason inside of her right now.
But her big round tits are heaving the more worked up she gets and all he can really think about is how much he wishes he could lean over and take one of her hard pink nipples into his mouth because they look so inviting, but that feels like the wrong thing to do right now. During this super important ceremony.
So Archie just keeps his hands on Cheryl's quivering, milky thighs, holding them apart as he continues to feed her his cock, pushing deeper into her with each go, trying to find that spot inside of her that will make her see stars.
He knows he's not the most experienced guy at school—maybe not even as experienced as Jason would have been—but Archie knows what he's doing and he knows how to make girls feel good, and he wants to make Cheryl feel good.
Because yes, this is some weird fucked up incest breeding ceremony, but it's also Cheryl's first time, and he wants hers to be special. And not just because it's in front of at least thirty board members of her family's company. He knows Jason would have made it special.
This ceremony may be about getting Cheryl pregnant, but that doesn't mean it can't be about making her feel amazing too, so when he thinks he's found what he's looking for, and Cheryl's pale, naked body starts to jolt like she's been shocked, Archie keeps going until he's making her tremble.
Cheryl comes dramatically and beautifully, loud moans spilling from her lips and making the crowd in front of them murmur their approval, and her clenching cunt feels so good around Archie's cock that he doesn't last much longer than she does.
He tries to keep fucking her through it, to draw her pleasure out and maybe give her more, but he's just feeling too much in this moment to hold back.
So Archie starts to come inside Cheryl before her own orgasm seems to have finished, canting into her a few more times before pushing his cock as deep inside her as he can before completely letting go.
Archie's cum leaves him in long, heavy spurts, his thick cock throbbing as he empties his sperm into Cheryl's ripe, waiting womb, breeding her like her family wants.
He doesn't know if this will be enough to get her pregnant, or what happens if it isn't, but as the Blossom board members applaud their efforts and Clifford Blossom comes up to pat him on the back while he's still inside his daughter, Archie can't help but think he wouldn't mind filling in for Jason again.