Work Text:
December
He said it the way he said most things that mattered — sideways, with his eyes somewhere else.
They were in the kitchen. Shane's kitchen, technically — the cottage that sat twenty minutes from where the Hollanders had raised their son, that Shane had bought in his second year with the Habs and which Ilya had, across the last few summers, quietly come to think of as theirs. It smelled like the pasta Shane had made and the candle Shane had found in a cupboard and lit without asking and which Ilya found he didn't mind at all. Shane had his back to him, rinsing dishes, and Ilya was leaning against the counter with a glass of wine he wasn't really drinking, watching the way the back of Shane's neck looked in the low light, the small notch of his spine, the way his shoulders had finally gone loose and easy after two days of being wound tight with the particular exhaustion that came from playing excellent hockey in front of a crowd that expected it as a minimum.
He'd been thinking about it for a while. The shape of what they were, the geometry of it — Shane in Montreal, Ilya in Ottawa, a five-hour drive between them that got crossed less often than either of them wanted and more often than was probably wise given what was at stake. He had moved to Ottawa for Shane, had sold most of his car collection for Shane, had built his whole life in this city around a person who came on weekends and holidays and for whole glorious weeks in summer. And it had seemed — it had been seeming, for months now, in the quiet of his apartment during the long stretches between visits — profoundly unfair. Shane had been gay his whole life and spent most of that life pretending otherwise. The only man he allowed himself was one he couldn't publicly claim. That didn't seem right.
He thought he was being generous. He would think about this word later — generous — what it actually meant, what it required. He would think about it for a very long time.
"You know," he said, to somewhere behind Shane's left shoulder. "If you wanted to be with other men. While we are apart. You could."
The water kept running for a moment. Then Shane turned it off.
The silence was not the silence of a man considering an offer. It was the silence of a man very carefully deciding which part of himself to hold onto.
"What?" Shane's voice was quiet. Even.
"I am just saying." Ilya set his wine glass down. "We are not together very much. It would not be—"
"If I wanted to." Shane turned around. His face was doing something Ilya had never seen before — a very careful, very controlled version of something terrible. "How long have you been thinking about this?"
"I don't know. A while."
"A while."
"Shane—"
"So this whole time." Shane's voice cracked on the second word and he covered it by looking at the ceiling, jaw working. "You've been standing there thinking that I'm — what? Suffering? That I'm out there desperately wanting other men and just holding myself back out of some misplaced loyalty to you?"
"That is not what I—"
"Or is this actually about you?" The question landed flat and terrible between them. "Is this how you tell me something?"
Ilya felt the floor tilt. He could see the exit — the true thing he should say, I am afraid I am not enough for you, I am afraid I am keeping you from a life that fits you better — and he looked directly at it and could not say it. Because saying it out loud meant it was real. Meant there was a real possibility that Shane would agree.
"I only thought you have not had much experience. I thought perhaps I was keeping you from something."
The thing that happened to Shane's face then was not anger, exactly. It was something worse. It was the face of someone watching a lock turn on a door they'd hoped would stay closed.
"Keeping me from something," Shane repeated.
"I did not mean it like—"
"No." Shane was already moving — reaching for his jacket, which was folded over the back of the kitchen chair. "I think you meant exactly that. I think you've been standing here looking at me like I'm some inexperienced kid who needs to go find himself, and I think that says a lot about how you actually see this."
"Shane—"
"I'm going to go." Said simply. Not dramatically. That was almost worse. "I'll text you when I'm home."
The drive from the cottage to the Hollanders' house was less than five minutes. Ilya knew this. He stood at the kitchen window until the headlights swept across the tree line and disappeared, and then stood there longer, looking at the dark where the car had been.
He thought about Yuna, who was almost certainly awake, who would hear the door, who would know from a single look at her son's face that something was wrong. Yuna who would ask the right questions. Yuna who was always the better speaker of the two of them.
He thought about David, who might also be awake, who watched everything quietly and said less than he understood.
He thought about Shane sitting at their kitchen table — his parents' table, the one Ilya had sat at more times than he could count, eating chicken parmesan and playing Yahtzee and feeling, with an astonishment that never fully faded, like he was allowed to be there.
The text came at eleven forty-seven.
Home.
Ilya stared at it. Typed I'm sorry. Deleted it. Typed call me. Deleted that too.
He put the phone face-down on the counter. The kitchen smelled like pasta and melted wax. The candle had burned down to nothing. The silence was the particular silence of a house that had had a person in it and now didn't.
***
December into February
He didn't call for four days.
He knew this wasn't fair. He knew Ilya's texts were accumulating unanswered — not many, because Ilya was not the type to flood someone's phone, but a few, careful and restrained in the way Ilya was careful and restrained about things he actually needed. Shane read every one. He did not respond to most of them. Every time he opened the thread he could feel the conversation waiting on the other side of it, and he was not ready to have it yet, and so he didn't.
On the fourth day he called from a hotel room in Philadelphia. It was late. The curtains were open on a grey slice of city and Shane was sitting on the edge of the bed looking at nothing in particular.
Ilya picked up on the second ring. "Shane."
Just his name. Low and careful. Like he'd been waiting.
"Did you mean it," Shane said. "That you wouldn't care."
A long pause. "No."
"Then why did you say it?"
"Because—" Ilya stopped. The careful, around-the-outside way he talked about things that mattered. "Because I thought you deserved—"
"Don't." Shane pressed the heel of his hand to his forehead. "Don't tell me what I deserve. Tell me what you actually want."
Silence.
"Ilya."
"I want you to be happy," Ilya said, and it was so perfectly, catastrophically wrong that Shane laughed — a short, ragged sound that surprised them both.
"I was happy," he said. "I was happy until you decided to improve the situation."
The silence stretched. Philadelphia outside, indifferent.
"I need some time," Shane said finally. "To think."
"Okay."
"I'm not ending this. I just need to think."
"Okay," Ilya said again. Then, quietly: "I am sorry, Shane."
"I know." Shane lay back on the hotel bed. "I know you are."
He meant to call in a week. The week became two. Ilya kept texting — not desperately, in the careful way he had of needing something while refusing to show it plainly. Shane wrote back to some of them. By February they were communicating with the warmth of two men who had once met briefly at a conference.
The thing about a silence that goes on long enough is that it settles into its own answer. Neither of them said the word over because over had to be said out loud and they were, between them, excellent at not saying things. The calls thinned and then stopped. The texts grew shorter and then stopped. In mid-February, Ilya's name stopped appearing on Shane's phone altogether, and Shane registered the date, filed it somewhere in the back of his mind with the careful helplessness of someone cataloguing a wound.
He told himself it was fine. That it was mutual. That neither of them saying the word meant nothing was permanent.
He told himself this almost every day. By March he almost believed it.
***
March
His name was Dominic. Physical therapist, thirty-two, dark-haired, the kind of ease that came from knowing what he looked like and being completely at peace with it. He found Shane at a fundraiser gala where Shane had spent the previous hour performing the specific function of NHL captain at fundraiser with the focused efficiency of someone running a subroutine.
Dominic looked at him like he found him interesting rather than impressive. After three months of grey suspended nothing, something in Shane turned toward it the way a plant turns toward a window.
He didn't think about Ilya. That was what he told himself in the cab on the way to Dominic's apartment. He wasn't going to think about Ilya. Ilya had offered him this — had, in his infuriating, self-sabotaging, emotionally constipated way, said you could — and Shane was going to take that at face value and live his life and be a person who had sex with men he was attracted to.
Dominic's apartment was clean and modern and smelled like cedar. He kissed well — confidently, his hands moving to Shane's jaw in a way that was practiced and genuinely kind.
Shane kissed back and waited to feel something dissolve.
The something did not dissolve. But his body responded, because it was twenty-eight years old and had a limited amount of patience for grief, and Dominic was attentive and warm and not doing anything wrong. He worked Shane's shirt open with deliberate hands and pressed his mouth to his throat and Shane stood still in the hallway and let it happen and thought: just be here. Just be a person in a room with another person. This is fine. This is what fine looks like.
He almost managed it, in stretches. Dominic was thorough and patient, and there were passages — Dominic's hands learning him, Dominic's mouth warm at his neck — where the noise went quiet and Shane could simply feel. He let himself sink into it. His body responded, generous and uncomplicated, and it was good. It was genuinely good.
Then Dominic shifted, his weight moving over Shane in a certain way, and something in Shane's body went very still.
It wasn't wrong. Dominic wasn't doing anything wrong. But something below conscious thought was running a register Shane hadn't authorized — cataloguing every difference with the relentless fidelity of something that had memorized an original and could not be fooled by a copy. The wrong scent: cedar, where there should have been something warmer and more specific, the particular warmth of Ilya's skin that Shane had memorized so completely he could reconstruct it in total darkness. The wrong hands: skilled and kind, but learning, navigating by instinct where Ilya navigated by knowledge accumulated over years of specifically paying attention to the specific person of Shane Hollander. The wrong weight. The wrong rhythm. The wrong cadence of breathing in the dark. The wrong way his name sounded in a mouth that had never said it the way Ilya said it — always slightly like a challenge, and somehow also like something handled with care.
He stayed. Because stopping would have been the admission of it, and he wasn't ready to admit anything yet. He stayed and he was present enough, and Dominic was satisfied, and when it was over Shane found a reason to leave that sounded real.
He sat in his car outside Dominic's building for five minutes and breathed.
His reflection in the rearview mirror looked like a man who had eaten when he wasn't hungry and still wasn't full.
He drove home. He did not call Ilya. He thought about it every mile.
***
March through May
He kept the appointments with Galina, which he considered a personal achievement, given that most mornings the appointment was the primary reason he got dressed.
She asked him how he was sleeping. He said adequately, which was not true. He was waking at three a.m. and lying in the dark with the particular silence of his Ottawa apartment pressing in around him. He had moved to this city for Shane. He had built his life around the shape of someone who came on weekends and holidays and for whole glorious weeks in summer, and now the shape was gone and the apartment was just an apartment, just rooms, and it was remarkable how much louder a space got when what you'd built it around had been removed.
"You ended things," Galina said. Not a question.
"We ended things," he corrected. Then: "I think. Neither of us actually said it."
"What did you say?"
"I said something I meant to be generous." He looked at the window. Ottawa in March. Still grey. "I told Shane he could be with other men. That I would not mind. I thought—" He stopped. "I thought I was being kind."
Galina was quiet for a moment. Then: "Were you?"
He thought about it honestly. "No. I think I was trying to say that I was afraid I wasn't enough for him. But I said it the wrong way, and then when he pushed back I said something worse, and then—" He exhaled. "Then I told myself he needed space. And then the space became the answer."
"Is there a pattern here?" Galina asked. "Of deciding what other people need rather than asking?"
He thought about his mother. About being twelve years old and trying to be very easy, very good, so she would not have to worry about him. About how she had told him once, years later, that it had made her feel lonely. That she couldn't reach him. He had not understood that at the time.
He was starting to understand it now.
He played well enough that season, because hockey was the one thing his body knew how to do regardless of what everything else was doing. He showed up. He scored adequate numbers. He was a good captain in the ways that captaining required presence and decisiveness and not showing too much of yourself.
Troy knocked on his door in March with no preamble except "food," which was becoming their shorthand for I can see you're not doing well and I am not going to make you talk about it but I am also not going to leave you alone. Ilya got his coat. He was grateful for Troy in the specific way he was grateful for things that didn't ask anything of him while still clearly caring whether he was okay.
At the diner, eating food that tasted like food again for the first time in weeks, Troy said to his coffee cup: "My brother came out last year. I didn't handle it perfectly at first." A pause. "Telling you in case it's ever useful."
Ilya looked at him.
"It is useful," Ilya said.
Troy nodded. They finished their food. Walking back to the arena, Troy said: "You doing okay?"
"No," Ilya said. "But I think I will be."
It was the most honest thing he'd said out loud in weeks. He didn't know if it was true yet.
He went to Sunday dinners at the Hollanders'. Still. Even now. Because David had called and asked and Ilya was incapable of saying no to David, who had looked at him in a hallway months ago with a quiet careful look and then simply made room for him without ceremony. He sat at their table and ate Yuna's food — she'd made yakitori one week, the smell of it filling the whole house — and answered David's questions about the season, and navigated the careful space around Shane's name with the practiced precision of people who all knew something and were all waiting for someone to say it first.
It was the best part of his week. Every week. He tried not to think too hard about what that meant.
***
April
His name was Will, and Shane met him through J.J., which was its own particular kind of irony.
J.J. had mentioned him with the careful casualness of someone who had thought about it quite a bit — a friend of a friend, recently out, works in sports medicine, very good person. Shane had seen through the construction immediately and been too tired to dismantle it. Will was thirty-one, sandy-haired, with the particular steadiness that came from spending your days at other people's worst moments and learning not to panic. He'd been out since university and had the ease of someone who had never had to perform a version of himself for an audience.
Shane liked him. This was the uncomfortable part. He genuinely, straightforwardly liked Will — who asked real questions and listened to the answers, who found Shane's various anxious tendencies more amusing than exhausting, who was funny in the specific way of someone who didn't need you to notice how funny he was.
They went out twice before anything happened, and by the third time Shane found himself thinking — tentatively, with effort, the way you put weight on an ankle you've twisted — maybe. Just that. The small bare beginning of something.
Will kissed him first, in the parking lot after dinner, warm and unhurried. Shane leaned into it. Maybe.
Will's apartment was lived-in and warm, full of books and plants — things that required tending, which struck Shane as a meaningful thing to notice about a person. Will was present in bed the way he was present everywhere else: actually paying attention, not running a routine. There were stretches where Shane was simply in it. Will's weight above him, Will's breath at his neck, the genuine good of being with someone who was actually trying to be good to you.
He thought: see. This can be enough. This is what enough looks like.
He tried the thought on. He wore it for a while and almost made it fit.
Then Will moved, settling behind him, his chest warm against Shane's back, and Shane felt his body do the thing.
He knew it now for what it was. He'd been through it once with Dominic. His body's quiet, faithful, completely involuntary audit: wrong scent, wrong hands, wrong weight. Will behind him, genuinely warm and kind and there, and Shane's body registering every departure from the original with the calm relentlessness of something that had made its decision years ago and saw no reason to revisit it. The wrong rhythm. The specific way someone breathed that was not the right specific way. The wrong murmur at his ear.
He stayed. He was present enough. Afterward Will turned to look at him with the directness he'd had throughout.
"You're somewhere else," Will said. Observing, not accusing.
Shane looked at the ceiling. "I'm trying not to be."
"I know." A pause. "Is it someone specific? Or just the idea of someone?"
The question landed somewhere Shane hadn't expected. He was quiet long enough to be an answer.
"You don't have to tell me," Will said. "But — if you're trying to get over someone, it might be worth asking yourself if that's actually what you want. Or just what you think you should want."
Shane looked at him. Will's face in the low light: steady, patient, not requiring anything back.
They saw each other four more times. Will remained patient and good, and Shane kept trying, and the trying kept failing in the same specific way, and they both knew it, and the kindness with which Will eventually received the ending was more than Shane deserved.
"Whoever it is," Will said, at the door, "they're lucky. Even if they don't know it."
Shane drove home and sat in the parking garage for twenty minutes before he could make himself go inside.
***
June and July
His name was Marcus, and Shane knew before it started that this one was different. Not safer. Scarier. He had actually worked to get here — had extended himself, had chosen this consciously rather than drifting into it. That meant something. He needed it to mean something.
Marcus worked in finance, but had played hockey through university and still watched obsessively, which meant he understood Shane's life without needing it explained. He was thirty-three, quietly funny, with a quality of listening that felt rare — still and focused, like what you said was actually landing rather than being waited through. He'd been out for years and wore it easily.
They met at a fundraiser — again, always fundraisers — and talked for three hours at the bar, which was longer than Shane had genuinely talked to anyone in months. Shane noticed things over the two dinners that followed: the way Marcus held his opinions with an open hand and was genuinely interested in being wrong. The way he never performed. The easy phone call to his mother on the walk back, unremarkable and affectionate, the kind that happened because you talked to your mother regularly and not because you were making a point of it.
Maybe, Shane thought. The third time thinking it, and he knew the pattern, and he told himself this time was different because he was choosing it properly.
He was choosing it. He was going to want it. He had decided.
The first night they spent together, Shane was present in a way he hadn't been with the others. He'd made the decision with his whole self, not just his surface, and it showed — he gave more, stayed closer, and Will had been right that what you put in mattered. Marcus was warm and genuinely attentive and had been paying attention to Shane specifically across several evenings, and there was something in being known — even partially, even recently — that Shane had been starving for without naming it.
There were stretches where he was simply in it. Long stretches. Longer than before. Marcus's hands, which had learned some of his responses, moving with a confidence that was earned. Shane's body responding, real and present, giving back what was being given. He thought: this. Here. This is what choosing feels like.
He held onto that thought. He held it carefully.
Then Marcus shifted behind him, his weight and warmth along Shane's back, and Shane felt his body begin its audit.
No, he thought. Not this time.
He pushed through it. He stayed present, stayed with the good of it, and it worked — for a while, for enough of it, the audit running quietly in the background where he could ignore it. Marcus's hands knew him. That was real. The warmth was real. He focused on the physical fact of what was good, which was considerable, and it was enough, mostly, until it wasn't.
Afterward, Marcus lay beside him in the dark and they were quiet together for a while, and Shane thought: maybe this is what enough actually is. Maybe I've been measuring it wrong.
He tried it on. He wore it in the dark of Marcus's bedroom for a few minutes and felt it not quite fit — the shape of it right but the size wrong, like something measured against the wrong template.
"You're thinking very loudly," Marcus said, after a while.
Shane exhaled. "Sorry."
"Don't apologize." A pause. "You want to talk about it?"
Shane looked at the ceiling. "I'm not sure I'm over someone," he said. First honest thing he'd said out loud in a long time. "I've been trying to be. I thought if I just — I don't know. Kept moving." He stopped. "It's not working."
"How long?"
"Seven months. Since it ended." He paused. "Since I started trying. Same day."
Marcus was quiet for a moment. Then: "Seven months is a long time to try something that isn't working." He said it gently, without drama. "Shane — I think you already know what you want to do."
Shane looked at him. Marcus's face: steady, patient, a genuinely good person who had given him more than he'd been able to give back.
"Yeah," Shane said. "I think I do."
He left before it was fully light. He drove home in the early morning and sat in his car in the underground garage and finally — exhausted, months too late — let himself think about Ilya without managing it.
Not the but he said and the but I should and the carefully maintained fiction that he was making progress. Just Ilya. The specific and unreasonable fact of him. The way he looked at Shane across arenas with the barely-contained intensity of someone trying to commit a thing to memory. The way he'd said you could, if you wanted and how Shane had heard I don't need you the way you need me when what had probably been meant was something closer to I am afraid you deserve more than I know how to give.
He thought about Sunday dinners at the Hollanders' table. He thought about the look on Ilya's face when David said something that made him feel included — the flicker of surprise that never quite left, even after years of being let in. He thought about Ilya eating ice cream out of a little bowl on the couch, tucked under a blanket, saying impossible to resist about cookies and cream in the way he said things that embarrassed him with their softness.
He thought about you could, if you wanted, and heard it, for the first time, the way it might have been meant — not indifference, not distance, but fear wearing the clothes of generosity. Ilya Rozanov who could not say I am afraid I am not enough for you directly and so had tried to say it sideways and broken them both entirely by accident.
He picked up his phone. Looked at Ilya's name for a long time.
Put it down. Not yet.
But not yet felt, for the first time, like a direction. Like a door that was going to open. Not a wall.
***
October
He'd been watching Ilya Rozanov play hockey for years.
Not just watching him the way you watched any player — tracking stats, following on a broadcast with general knowledge. He'd learned to watch Ilya the way he'd learned to watch Shane: closely, with attention to what the cameras missed. The small tells that lived in footwork and posture and the set of a jaw between whistles. Shane had always been readable to him at a distance, even through a television screen. He could tell within the first period whether his son was carrying something.
It had taken longer to learn to read Ilya. But he'd had years now. And Ilya, underneath the considerable performance of being Ilya Rozanov, was not as different from Shane as either of them would probably want to believe.
He didn't know exactly when he'd become genuinely fond of him. There had been no decision, no moment of it. It had just happened, gradually and then completely, the way things happened between people who spent enough time at the same table. Maybe it was the way Ilya ate Yuna's food — with the intensity of someone who hadn't always been sure there would be enough. Maybe it was the Sunday he'd caught Ilya standing at the mantel looking at photographs of Shane at seventeen with an expression he hadn't known anyone was watching. Maybe it was how he said full from the delicious dinner with the small smile he wore when he was happier than he intended, and the way it made it obvious that being welcome somewhere still surprised him, every time.
He'd always understood something about a person who was surprised to be welcome. He'd raised one.
He watched Ottawa play on a Tuesday in early October, alone in the living room with the sound turned low so Yuna could sleep. She'd seen the game once already at her gym and declared it depressing; she was right. Ottawa was down by two in the second period.
Ilya's play had been wrong all season in a way David had been trying to name. Not injured-wrong. Not tired-wrong, though there was exhaustion in it. Something more interior. It lived in the hesitations — the split-second delays that weren't there in a healthy year, the way he held himself on the bench between shifts like a man keeping himself contained rather than a man who was resting. The way, when the camera caught him between plays, he looked at nothing in particular.
David had watched his son look at nothing in particular for most of a year. He recognized the specific texture of it.
Late in the third, Ottawa pulled a goal back on a play Ilya set up with a pass that was, technically, perfect — the right play, the right read, exactly what was called for. The crowd responded. Ilya's linemates celebrated. The broadcast cut to him after, catching the fraction of a second before he'd arranged his face, before the game-face went back on — and in that fraction David saw a man who had forgotten, briefly, what any of this was supposed to be for.
He sat with it after the game. He thought about September, when Ilya had come to dinner and sat at their table and eaten less than usual, which for Ilya was remarkable. He thought about October, when Ilya had missed dinner twice. Both times he'd texted with an excuse. Both times David had checked, gently and without mentioning it, and found the excuses were not quite true.
Ilya had never missed Sunday dinner before. Not once, in all the years David had been asking him.
He went to bed. In the morning he made coffee and sat at the kitchen table in the particular quiet of early morning, looking at the chair where Ilya usually sat.
Then he picked up his phone and called his son.
***
His father called on a Thursday morning. His father texted. That was the system — a constant family thread, photos and observations and the occasional hockey commentary, but not calls. Not unless it was a birthday or something that couldn't wait.
"Dad." Shane answered on the second ring. "Is everyone okay?"
"Everyone's fine." His father's voice: steady, unhurried. "I need to talk to you about something. About Ilya."
Shane went still at the kitchen counter.
"I've been watching him play all season," his father said. "Something's wrong with him. Not hockey-wrong. I can see it in the way he — the way he holds himself, between plays. The way he looks when he thinks no one's watching." A pause. "You know what I mean."
Shane did know. He knew immediately and completely, in the specific way of someone who had learned to read a person the way his father had learned to read him.
"He's been coming to dinner," his father continued, "but he missed twice in October. Both times he said he had something. I checked the schedule." A brief silence. "He didn't have anything, Shane."
Shane pressed his palm flat against the counter.
"He's not eating right," his father said. "When he comes. Yuna noticed before I did — she says he's thinner. And the way he is at the table, he's there but he's not quite—" He stopped, finding the word. "He's not all the way there. You know how he usually is when he's comfortable. He's not that."
Shane knew. He knew exactly. He'd been the one to make Ilya comfortable there in the first place, years of Sunday evenings and chicken parmesan and Yahtzee until it had simply become the shape of things — Ilya at their table, Ilya on their couch, Ilya saying impossible to resist about cookies and cream ice cream with the small delighted smile he wore when he forgot to be guarded.
"I know it's not my place," his father said. "Whatever happened between you two is yours. I'm not asking. But—" A pause. "He's got no one else, son. Not really. We're what he has here. And something's gotten bad enough that he's not coming, and he's not saying why. And that worries me more than if he'd called and told me himself."
Shane stood at his kitchen counter and looked at the tap, which was dripping, which he had meant to fix for three weeks.
"Yeah," he said. His voice came out rough. "Yeah, Dad. Thank you."
"He's in Ottawa," his father said. A pause that contained several things he was choosing not to say. "Mid-season. Don't wait too long."
Shane was in his car seventeen minutes later.
***
He drove the almost five hours in the dark. He stopped once for gas and coffee and stood in the fluorescent buzz of a highway rest stop thinking about what he was doing and deciding that it didn't matter — he was already doing it, and the doing of it was the thing that needed doing, and overthinking it wasn't going to change anything.
He parked outside Ilya's building at eleven-fifteen. Buzzed the apartment. Nothing. Buzzed again, longer.
Ilya's voice through the intercom: rough with something that wasn't quite sleep. "What."
"It's me."
A silence that lasted long enough to feel like it was deciding something. Then the door clicked open.
The elevator was slow. Shane stood in it and looked at his reflection in the brushed-steel doors — travel-wrinkled, slightly hollow-eyed, empty-handed because he'd left so fast he'd forgotten to bring anything — and thought: okay. You're here. That's the thing you needed to do. Just be here.
Ilya's door was ajar. Not open — ajar, the way it was when someone had unlocked it and retreated. Shane pushed it and went inside.
The apartment was dark except for the lamp in the living room at its lowest setting. It had the quality of a space that had been like this for a while — not the comfortable dark of somewhere someone was resting, but the particular dark of somewhere someone had stopped bothering with lights. The kind of dark that accumulated when you weren't really living in a space so much as occupying it.
Ilya was on the couch. Not lying down, just sitting, with the loose unguarded slump of someone who'd been there long enough that their body had stopped performing posture. He was thinner — Shane's father had been right and seeing it in person hit differently than hearing it. Longer hair than Shane had seen in years. And something in his face that wasn't grief, which was at least an active thing, but something hollower — a flatness, a dimming, like the lights behind his eyes had been turned down to their minimum setting and had not come back up.
He looked at Shane without expression.
"What are you doing here," he said. Not quite a question.
"My dad called me." Shane stayed near the door for a moment, just looking at him. Taking stock of everything his father had been trying to describe. "You missed dinner twice. He checked the schedule."
Something moved in Ilya's face. There and gone.
"He should not have—"
"He was worried." Shane crossed the room. He crouched in front of the couch, putting himself at Ilya's level, in his eyeline. Up close it was worse — the shadows under his eyes, the particular tightness around his mouth of someone who had been managing themselves very carefully for a very long time and was exhausted by it. "How long has it been like this?"
"Like what."
"Ilya."
A pause that meant he was deciding whether to be honest. Then, to the floor: "Since January."
January. The phone call. The silence that became an answer.
"Why didn't you—"
"What would I have said?" The flatness cracked, just enough to hear what was underneath it. "You were moving on. You were doing what you needed to do. I was not going to call you and—" He stopped.
"And what?"
"And make myself your problem."
Shane closed his eyes briefly. Opened them. "You are not my problem," he said, and it came out harder than he meant it, hard enough that Ilya looked at him. "You have never been my problem. You're the—" He stopped. Tried again. "I've spent ten months trying to get over you. I've been with other men. Three of them." He watched Ilya's face. Watched the flatness shift, change, something moving underneath it. "Every single time I was somewhere else. Every time, no matter how hard I tried to be present, I was somewhere else. And the somewhere else was always the same place."
Ilya's jaw moved. He looked at the ceiling. His eyes were bright in a way the low lamp couldn't account for.
"I should have called you in February," Shane said. "I should have called you in March. I was angry and hurt and I kept waiting to feel differently and I never felt differently, I just got very good at pretending I did." He moved from the crouch to the couch, sitting right beside him. He put his hand on Ilya's back. Felt him go rigid. Kept it there. "You said something stupid in December. I know why you said it and it was still stupid. And I was too proud to call you and tell you that you were wrong about what I wanted, and so we both—" He exhaled. "We both made it worse."
Ilya was doing the thing. Shane had only seen it twice in all the years he'd known him — the composure coming apart not all at once but in pieces, the careful assembled steadiness failing at the joints. His breath went ragged. His shoulders moved. He put his face in his hands, and the sound that came out of him was low and unwilling and terrible, the sound of something that had been held too long in too small a space.
Shane sat beside him and kept his hand moving in a slow circle on his back and didn't say anything, because there was nothing to say that would be better than this. Just being here. Not leaving.
It took a while. Ilya cried the way people who didn't do it often enough cried — badly and honestly, for what sounded like several accumulated things at once, not just this but the whole winter and the silence and probably some things that went back further than that. Shane sat with him through all of it.
Gradually, the sounds stopped. Ilya stayed with his face in his hands for another long moment. Then he lowered them and sat very still, and Shane could see him reassembling — not back into the flatness, not back into the careful nothing, but into something that looked more like the real one.
"I'm going to make you eat something," Shane said.
The sound Ilya made was not quite a laugh. Almost.
"Is that funny?" Shane said.
"No." A pause. "I don't know what I have in there."
"I'll figure it out."
He made eggs and toast because those were the things he could find. He made enough for two and put a plate in front of Ilya and sat across from him and didn't make it a thing. Ilya ate all of it. All of it, which told its own story. Shane watched him do it and felt something in his chest that was not uncomplicated — the specific gravity of caring about someone completely, the weight of it, which was not at all the same as the lighter version he'd carried in the earlier years when it had seemed more manageable.
When the plates were done Ilya leaned back in his chair and looked at Shane with eyes that were still tired, still raw at the edges, but actually present in a way they hadn't been when Shane walked in.
"You drove five hours," Ilya said.
"Almost five."
"At midnight."
"Eleven-fifteen." Shane stood and collected the plates. "And you're coming to Sunday dinner."
"Shane—"
"My dad is going to ask you himself. In person. There is no avoiding it and you know it."
A pause. Something moved across Ilya's face — the small involuntary softening Shane had been cataloguing for years, the one he only ever saw when Ilya forgot to be guarded.
"I know what David's asking-directly looks like," Ilya said.
"Then you know there's no use resisting."
"I will come," Ilya said. Quietly. Like it meant something, which it did. "Sunday."
"Good." Shane ran water over the plates. "You're going to eat."
"I always eat at your parents'."
"You barely touched it in September. My mother noticed."
A silence. Then: "Your father notices everything."
"Yes," Shane said. "He does."
***
The bedroom was dark except for the ambient light of the city through the curtains — Ottawa at midnight, quiet enough that Shane could hear the low hum of the building around them, the ordinary contained sound of a life being lived.
Ilya stood at the edge of the bed with the particular hesitation of someone who had been in a bad place for a long time and wasn't quite sure how to inhabit a good one. Shane came to stand in front of him.
"You don't have to—" Ilya started.
"I want to," Shane said. He put his hands on either side of Ilya's face — the familiar geography of it, which his hands knew completely, which ten months had not made unfamiliar. "Do you want to?"
Ilya looked at him. His eyes, close up, were still tired, still slightly raw around the edges. But present. Completely present, in the specific way that was different from any other kind of being looked at — Ilya's full attention, which had always cost Shane something to receive, which had never once felt like less than it was.
"Yes," he said.
"Okay," Shane said. "Come here."
He kissed him slowly. Ilya kissed back with a careful intensity — testing the reality of it, checking that this was actually happening — and Shane let him check. Let him take his time. Ilya's hands came to Shane's face, both of them, thumbs at his jaw, tilting him the way he always did when he was paying full attention, and Shane felt it in the center of his chest like a chord resolving into the thing it had been reaching toward for ten months.
They moved to the bed without urgency. Shane pulled Ilya's shirt over his head and ran his hands down his chest and sides, relearning the slight changes that ten months had made — the thinness, the different way he was holding tension, the evidence of a hard winter written in the lines of him — and took his time with it, because time was the point now. Being unhurried with a person because you were staying.
"Your hands," Ilya said quietly. He said it to the ceiling, the way he said things he meant more than he wanted to.
"What about them."
"I have thought about them. Specifically."
Shane looked up at him. "Just my hands?"
A beat. "No." Ilya brought his gaze down to meet Shane's. The look: direct, complete, nothing managed out of it. "Not only your hands."
Shane smiled. Ilya's face did the thing it only did for him — the very small, involuntary softening at the corners that no one else had probably ever seen, that Shane had been keeping a private record of for years. Shane kissed him again, less carefully.
They undressed each other in pieces, unhurried, relearning by degree. Ilya moved over him with the slow thoroughness he used when he wasn't rushing, when something mattered enough to take seriously. His mouth at Shane's collarbone, his chest, the long plane of his sternum. Shane lay back and let the apartment be the apartment and tried simply to be in a moment without managing it, which was the thing he was normally terrible at and which was, here, easier than it had ever been anywhere else.
He thought about it briefly — all three of them, Dominic and Will and Marcus — not with grief or guilt but with the clear-eyed recognition of someone who understood now what the months had actually been. The body running its faithful audit every time, noting the differences, running the comparison it had no permission to run. Because his body had made its decision years ago, quietly and without consulting him, and nothing Shane had done in ten months had been able to argue it out of it.
He wasn't thinking about any of them when Ilya's mouth reached his stomach.
He wasn't thinking about anything.
"Ilya," Shane said. Not a word exactly. An acknowledgment.
Ilya hummed against him, which was profoundly and deliberately unfair. Shane's hand found his hair and stayed there.
When Ilya moved back up over him, his weight settling over Shane's, Shane pulled him in by the back of the neck and kissed him with ten months of accumulated missing him. Ilya made a low rough sound and kissed back with something that had been accumulating on his end too, clearly, for just as long.
"I need—" Shane said against his mouth.
"I know," Ilya said, already reaching. "I have—"
"Yeah."
Shane turned onto his stomach and pressed his face into the pillow. The pillow smelled like Ilya — that specific warm scent, the one he had spent ten months reconstructing from memory with the faithfulness of obsession and had never quite gotten right, because you could not reconstruct it. You could only have it. He breathed it in and felt something in him, something that had been held tight for a very long time, begin to unclench.
Ilya's hands moved over his back, his sides, the curve of his hips — certain and warm, the hands of someone who had learned him so completely that navigation was no longer the right word for it. Confirming, maybe. Returning. Shane felt the warmth of his palms and thought: here. Finally. Here.
Ilya bent to press his mouth between Shane's shoulder blades. Shane felt the exhale of his breath against his spine and understood, with a clarity that had nothing to do with thought, that this was what cold actually was — the absence of this specific warmth in this specific place, which he had been cold without since January.
The preparation was slow and thorough and Ilya was murmuring in Russian under his breath, the way he did when he was concentrating on something that mattered, and Shane was making sounds into the pillow that he'd stopped being embarrassed about years ago. Ilya's fingers knowing what they were doing — knowing specifically Shane, the particular knowledge that accumulated from sustained and specific attention over years, and the difference between this and every night of the last ten months was the difference between a translation and the original. Something true where there had been something approximate. Something real where there had been something that was only trying to be.
"Okay," Shane said, which meant something specific between them, something Ilya knew.
The first slow push of Ilya moving into him made Shane's hands grip the sheets and his eyes close and everything else go briefly, completely white. He made a sound he had no control over. Ilya went still, his chest warm against Shane's back, his face pressed to the nape of his neck, both of them breathing together for a moment in the dark.
"Okay?" Ilya's voice was nearly nothing.
"Yes," Shane said. "Yes. Don't stop."
Ilya moved, and they found it — the rhythm that was theirs, the specific conversation they'd been having for years in the only language that required nothing to be performed, where being known was not something you worked for but simply something that existed, accumulated, returned to. Shane turned his face to the side and said "more" and Ilya gave him more, the rhythm building until Ilya's breath was rough at his neck and his hand was beneath Shane and Shane said fuck and meant it in every dimension available to him.
"Shane," Ilya said, low and wrecked, against his neck. Not a challenge. Not a performance. Just his name, which was its own kind of thing in Ilya's voice — always slightly like it cost him something, and said anyway.
"I'm here," Shane said. "I'm not going anywhere."
"Promise me." The rhythm hitching slightly on it. "Promise—"
"I promise," Shane said. "I'm not going anywhere. Come on—"
They came apart together, or close enough that the distinction didn't matter — Shane first and then Ilya ten seconds behind him, his weight dropping over Shane's back. Warm and solid and present in the specific irreplaceable way he was, the way that had no copy and no substitute, that Shane had spent ten months failing to account for.
For a long time they just breathed.
Ottawa outside, quiet. The low hum of the building. Ilya's weight over him, the slow settling of his breathing into something easier.
Shane became aware of Ilya's face in his hair. Ilya's arm over him, heavy and certain.
"Hey," Shane said.
"Hey," Ilya said.
The room was quiet. Shane thought about nothing for a stretch of time he couldn't measure, which was something he had not been able to do in ten months. Eventually:
"Sunday," Shane said.
"I said I would come."
"I know. I just want to hear it again."
A pause. Then, with something in it that was almost a smile: "Sunday dinner. I will eat everything. I will bring hand pies."
"Cherry ones."
"Obviously cherry ones."
"Good." Shane turned so he could look at him. Ilya, tired and raw and present, looking back at him with the full unguarded look he'd been showing Shane since before either of them had words for what it meant. "We're going to do this better."
"Yes," Ilya said.
"You're going to tell me when things are bad. Not just Galina. Me."
"Yes."
"And I'm going to call when I'm being an idiot instead of waiting ten months."
"This would be a significant improvement," Ilya said.
"We're both terrible at it."
"Yes." A pause. "But we are good at other things."
Shane looked at him for a moment. Then: "Yeah," he said. "We are."
Outside, Ottawa in October — the first real cold in the air, the city quiet and dark. Ilya's hand finding Shane's in the sheets, fingers threading together in the way they'd been doing for years, the weight and warmth of it that ten months and three men and one long year of being wrong had failed — completely, stubbornly, definitively — to find a replacement for.
Shane closed his eyes.
The apartment was quiet.
Stay, Ilya had said. Not in words — in the way he held on, in promise me, in the specific way he said Shane's name in the dark like it cost him something and he was paying it anyway.
I already am, Shane said back. The same way.
That was enough. It was more than enough. It was, in the only accounting that had ever mattered, everything.