Work Text:
Part One: The Wound
The church smelled of incense, old wood, and rain.
Father Matthew Murdock knelt before the altar long after midnight, his back straight, his hands folded. The tabernacle lamp cast a single red thread of light across the stone floor , the only color in the dark. He'd been a priest for seven years. He'd buried his mother, baptized a hundred babies, held the hands of the dying as they took their last breaths. He thought he'd seen every shape temptation could wear.
He was wrong.
The knock on the heavy oak doors came at 12:47 AM.
Matt didn't startle. He'd heard the footsteps ten minutes ago soft, deliberate, circling the nave like a wolf testing a fence. One set of shoes. One heartbeat. Fast but not frightened. Fast like a man counting down to something inevitable.
"The church is closed," Matt called out without turning around. His voice echoed off the vaulted ceiling.
The knocking stopped. A pause. Then a voice , smooth, Southern, pleasant in the way a razor blade is pleasant. Bright. Thin. Capable of drawing blood before you feel it.
"I'm not here for the church, Father. I'm here for you."
Matt stood slowly. Turned. His sightless eyes pointed toward the sound , and toward the smell of copper threading through the incense.
"You're bleeding."
"A little." A soft laugh. "Maybe more than a little."
The man stepped into the red glow of the tabernacle lamp. Matt's other senses painted him in vivid detail: tall, lean, dressed in a denim jacket that had once been expensive. Dark hair falling over a high forehead. A face that probably smiled easily and meant none of it. A pulse that was steady , too steady for a man who'd lost blood. Controlled. And beneath the leather and denim, the sharp chemical scent of antiseptic and fresh gauze.
The wound wasn't fresh. It had been dressed recently. Reopened on purpose.
"You could have gone to a hospital," Matt said quietly. "But you came here instead. Why?"
The man tilted his head. Matt heard the faint crack of his neck. "Because hospitals ask questions. You just listen."
"What's your name?"
"Benjamin Poindexter." He said it like a gift. Or a threat. "Though I suppose you'd prefer the name I was given at baptism, if I ever had one."
"Your name doesn't matter to God. Your heart does."
Dex laughed low and warm, bouncing off the pews and coming back wrong. "Father, if you could see my heart, you'd lock the doors and throw away the key."
Mat stepped closer. Not toward Dex ,toward the small sacristy off the side of the altar. "I have a medical kit. Let me look at that wound."
"You want to touch me."
"I want to help you."
Dex was quiet for a moment. Then: "Those are the same thing for you, aren't they? Touch is how you see. How you understand. You're not offering bandages. You're offering to know me."
Matt stopped walking. His hand found the doorframe of the sacristy. "You've done your research."
"I've done my homework." Dex's voice came from closer now. Matt hadn't heard him move. That was deliberate -a show of control. "You're Father Matthew Murdock. Ordained seven years ago. You run this parish and the shelter on Clinton Street. You take your coffee black with one sugar. You leave your apartment door unlocked because you believe in grace more than you believe in locks." A pause. "You say the same prayer every night before bed , the one about humility. And you don't know I was outside your window three nights ago, listening."
Matt's jaw tightened. His pulse didn't spike - he wouldn't give Dex that satisfaction. But his hands curled into fists at his sides.
"You're stalking a priest," Matt said flatly. "That's a new low, even for someone who smells like a gun."
"I'm not armed."
"I didn't say you were."
Dex laughed again - genuine this time, surprised. "You're sharp. I like that."
"Most people do until I cut them."
The silence between them stretched, thick and electric. Matt could feel Dex's eyes on him , not sight, but something like it. Pressure. Attention. The weight of being truly seen by someone who wanted something from him.
"Let me bandage the wound," Matt said finally. "Then you leave. No confession. No games. Just a man helping another man."
"And if I want more than that?"
"Then you leave anyway."
Dex was quiet. Matt heard him consider it — the small shifts in his breathing, the way his weight settled onto his heels.
"Fine," Dex said. "Bandage me, Father. But I'm not promising I'll stay on my side of the screen."
---
Part Two: The Touch
The sacristy was small - a narrow room with a stone sink, a wooden cabinet, and a single candle burning on the shelf. Matt moved by memory: antiseptic from the second drawer, gauze from the third, scissors from the hook by the mirror he'd never needed.
"Sit," Matt said, gesturing toward the plain wooden chair against the wall.
Dex sat. Matt heard the chair creak under his weight.
"I need to see it," Matt said. "Take off the jacket."
"You first."
Matt's hand stilled on the gauze. "What?"
"Take off your collar." Dex's voice was soft. Not demanding. Curious. "Just for a minute. I want to see you without it."
"That's not going to happen."
"Then I'll keep my jacket on." Dex leaned back in the chair. Matt heard the denim scrape against the wood. "We can sit here all night, Father. I've got nowhere to be."
Matt stood in the center of the small room, holding the gauze and antiseptic, breathing through his nose. He could walk out. He could call the police. He could do a dozen things that didn't involve standing here while a strange man played games with him.
But Dex was bleeding. Real blood - Matt could smell it, fresh and sharp beneath the antiseptic Dex had already applied. And bleeding men didn't always think clearly. Bleeding men said things they didn't mean, did things they wouldn't do.
That's what you're telling yourself, a voice whispered. That he's not in control. But you know he is.
Matt set the gauze down on the sink.
His hands went to his collar.
It was small - a white plastic tab at his throat, barely visible against his black shirt. He'd put it on every morning for seven years. He'd taken it off every night, alone in his apartment, and felt the ghost of it linger against his skin.
He unclipped it now. Slowly. Deliberately. The plastic tab came away in his fingers. He set it on the shelf beside the candle.
"I can't see it," Dex said. His voice had changed - rougher. "But I know it's gone. You look different."
"You can't see anything."
"I can see everything that matters." Dex shifted in the chair. "Now come here. Fix me."
Matt crossed the small room. He knelt in front of the chair ,not because Dex told him to, but because the wound was in Dex's side, and this was the angle that made sense. His knees pressed into the cold stone floor.
"Lift your shirt," Matt said.
Dex lifted.
Matt's fingers found bare skin first ,warm, smooth, the muscle beneath taut. Then they found the bandage Dex had already applied: crooked, peeling at the edges, soaked through with blood that was still tacky.
"You did this yourself," Matt said.
"I'm resourceful."
"You reopened it on purpose. Before you came here."
Dex didn't answer. Matt felt his pulse jump , just once, just enough to confirm the truth.
"Why?" Matt asked.
"Because I wanted you to touch me." Dex said it simply. Like it was obvious. "And I knew you wouldn't say no to a bleeding man."
Matt's hands hovered over the wound. He could feel the heat of Dex's skin, the slow seep of blood. His thumb brushed the edge of the cut - not on purpose, just to gauge the depth.
Dex inhaled sharply.
"Sorry," Matt murmured.
"No you're not."
Matt peeled away the old bandage. Dex hissed through his teeth. The wound was shallow , a knife cut, maybe, or broken glass. It needed cleaning and fresh gauze. Nothing more.
"You'll live," Matt said.
"Disappointed?"
"I'm a priest. I don't wish death on anyone."
"Not even the people who stalk you?"
Matt uncapped the antiseptic. "Especially not them."
He poured it over the wound. Dex gasped ، a real sound, not performed , and his hand came down on Matt's shoulder. Grip tight. Fingers digging in.
"Easy," Matt said.
"You could warn a person."
"I did. I said 'easy.'"
Dex laughed , breathless, pained, genuine. "You're enjoying this."
Matt pressed the fresh gauze against the wound. His palm flattened over Dex's side. Warmth spread through the thin fabric ، blood and something else. Something that made Matt's throat tight.
"I'm not enjoying anything," Matt said. "I'm doing my job."
"Your job is saving souls. Not stitching up crimials."
"You're a child of God. Same as anyone."
Dex's hand was still on Matt's shoulder. His thumb moved ,just a little, just a stroke against Matt's neck. Matt went very still.
"Don't," Matt said.
"Don't what?"
"Don't touch me like that."
Dex's thumb stopped. But his hand didn't move. "Like what?"
"Like I'm something you get to want."
The silence was enormous. Matt could hear the candle flickering. His own heartbeat. Dex's heartbeat, slower now, more deliberate.
"I've been watching you for six weeks," Dex said quietly. "Not because I want to hurt you. Because I can't look away. You move through the world like you're holding something fragile ,your faith, your vows, your stupid unlocked door. And I keep thinking: What would it take? What would it take for him to put all of that down? Just for a minute. Just for me."
Matt's hand was still pressed against Dex's side. The gauze was already reddening.
"Nothing," Matt said. "Nothing would make me put it down."
"You're lying." Dex's fingers curled into the fabric of Matt's shirt collar ,the empty space where the white tab used to be. "You already put down the collar. That was the first thing."
Matt pulled back. His hand left Dex's side. He sat back on his heels, putting a foot of cold air between them.
"I need you to leave now."
"I need you to look at me." Dex leaned forward. Matt felt the heat of his face , inches away. "Not with your eyes. With the other thing you do. The radar thing. I know about it. I want you to see me, Matt."
Matt's breath caught. No one called him Matt. Not here. Not in this building, in this role. He was Father Murdock. He was the collar, the vows, the safe distance.
Dex had taken the collar. And now he was asking for the rest.
"Say my name again," Dex whispered. "Like you did before. In the confessional."
Matt shook his head. "I can't."
"You can. You just won't."
"That's the same thing."
"It's not." Dex's hand found Matt's cheek. Light. Barely there. Matt could have turned his head. Could have stood up. Could have walked out of the sacristy and locked the door and never thought about Benjamin Poindexter again.
He didn't move.
"You're not stopping me," Dex said.
"I'm not helping you either."
"You're still here."
Matt closed his eyes. The darkness behind his lids was the same as the darkness in front of them ,endless, familiar, safe. But Dex's hand was warm on his cheek. Dex's blood was on his fingers. Dex's heartbeat was steady and close and wanting.
"What do you want from me?" Matt asked. His voice cracked. He hated that it cracked.
"Everything." Dex said it like it was simple. Like it was a glass of water. "But I'll start with this: tell me you feel it. The thing between us. The pull. Tell me I'm not crazy."
Matt's throat worked. His hands were shaking - he couldn't hide that from Dex's touch, from Dex's proximity.
"I feel it," Matt whispered. "But that doesn't mean I get to act on it."
"It means you're human."
"It means I'm weak."
Dex's thumb traced Matt's cheekbone. Gentle. Almost reverent. "That's not weakness, Matthew. That's the opposite of weakness. You've been fighting this for six weeks — longer, maybe. You've been praying harder, working later, sleeping less. You've been running from me inside your own head. And you're exhausted." A pause. "Let me hold you. Just for a minute. Just to rest."
Matt's eyes burned. He didn't cry , not yet. But it was close.
"If I let you hold me," Matt said, "I won't want you to stop."
"Then don't stop."
Matt's hand came up , slow, trembling , and covered Dex's on his cheek.
"One minute," Matt said.
"One minute."
Dex pulled him forward. Not rough ,gentle. His arms came around Matt's shoulders, and Matt let himself be gathered, let his forehead press into Dex's chest, let his weight tip forward until he was kneeling between Dex's knees, held upright by nothing but Dex's arms.
The denim jacket was rough against Matt's cheek. Beneath it, Dex's heart was pounding. Fast now. Real.
"You're crying," Dex said.
Matt hadn't noticed. But now he felt it , the hot trail down his cheek, the salt on his lip. Tears. Silent and long-suppressed.
"I'm sorry," Matt said into Dex's chest. "I don't know wh'
"Shh." Dex's hand came up to Matt's hair. Stroked. Slow. "You don't have to know. You just have to stay."
Dex's thumb found the tear on Matt's cheek. Wiped it away. Gentle. Deliberate. Then he brought his thumb to his own lips. Tasted.
"Salt and grief," Dex murmured. "You taste like every prayer you never finished."
Matt sobbed once ,a small, broken sound that he swallowed immediately.
Dex's hand cupped his jaw. Lifted his face. And then Dex leaned in and kissed Matt's cheek , right where the tear had been. Soft. Almost reverent.
Then the other cheek. Another tear. Another kiss.
"Stop," Matt breathed. But his hands were fisted in Dex's jacket, and he wasn't pushing away.
"I won't do anything you don't want," Dex said against his skin. "Tell me to stop, and I stop. Tell me to go, and I go. But don't tell me to stop wanting you. I can't do that."
Matt turned his head. His lips brushed the corner of Dex's mouth , not a kiss, just a question.
"Is this a sin?" Matt whispered.
"Probably." Dex's breath was warm. "Does that scare you?"
"It should."
"But it doesn't."
Matt closed the distance.
The kiss was soft. Tentative. Matt's first kiss in seven years -and it tasted like blood and antiseptic and the end of something he'd spent a decade building. Dex's lips parted beneath his. Dex's hand slid into Matt's hair. Dex made a sound - low, pained, grateful -and pulled Matt closer.
When they broke apart, Matt was shaking.
"That was one minute," Dex said. His voice was unsteady. Good. Matt was glad it wasn't just him.
"That was thirty seconds."
Dex laughed -breathless, real. "Then we have thirty left."
Matt kissed him again. Longer this time. Deeper. His hands found Dex's shoulders, then his neck, then his jaw. He kissed like a man drowning - because he was. In Dex's scent. In the heat of his skin. In the terrible freedom of not being Father Murdock for thirty more seconds.
When the minute ended, Matt pulled back.
Dex's hands stayed on his shoulders. Light. Asking.
"Same time tomorrow?" Dex said.
Matt wiped his face with the back of his hand. His cheeks were wet. His lips were swollen. His collar was still on the shelf.
"The church closes at nine."
"I'll come at midnight."
Matt stood. His knees ached from the stone floor. His hands were stained with Dex's blood. His mouth tasted like sin.
He picked up the collar. Held it for a long moment.
Then he put it back on.
Dex watched -Matt felt the weight of his gaze - and said nothing.
Matt walked him to the door. Dex paused on the threshold. The rain had started again - cold, clean, washing the street.
"For what it's worth," Dex said without turning around, "I think God would forgive you. For all of it."
Matt leaned against the doorframe. The collar was tight against his throat.
"Get that wound looked at by a real doctor," Matt said.
Dex smiled - Matt heard it in his voice. "See you tomorrow, Father."
He walked into the rain. Matt listened until the footsteps faded, until the heartbeat was swallowed by the city.
Then he went back inside, knelt before the altar, and tried to pray.
The words wouldn't come.
But for the first time in seven years, that felt less like failure and more like the beginning of something true.