1 - 20 of 160 Bookmarks by CrypticPaw
Navigation
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
"Well, well. What have we here?"
Shadow Milk cups his cheek, deep blue eyes taking in his newfound mate in front of him. If Pure Vanilla didn't know any better, he would swear that he was being evaluated. The smirk that plays on his face is cutting, and confident. Even now, in this brief moment of meeting for the first time—
Pure Vanilla finds himself intrigued.
Shadow Milk was like no one he had ever met before.
And yet, if he had one word to describe him, it would be captivating.
Every part of him is screaming at him to drown himself in the scent that surrounds him in every direction, and for the first time, Pure Vanilla understands all the murmurs he had heard among the villagers about the natural order of things for omegas.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
01 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The spell that Pure Vanilla performed to seal Dark Enchantress Cookie in the final moments of the Dark Flour War sent him hurdling back in time to the era of the Virtues.
There, as the amnesic Healer Cookie, he met the Fount of Knowledge.They grew closer, they fell in love, they made vows to each other.
Then it fell apart.
Then Healer Cookie ended up back in his time.
Then Healer Cookie awoke to his memories as Pure Vanilla Cookie, the ancient Hero of Truth.
What happened...what happened to his dear Fount?
Maybe he'll find the answers as he retraces White Lily's steps in Beast-Yeast.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
24 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Shadow Milk only wanted a meal to stave off the hunger gnawing at his stomach- fetch a human, prey on it and call it a day before going back to his privileged and dreadfully boring existence.
When a vampire came knocking down his door and asking if he could eat him, Pure Vanilla had understandably thought that this was the end for him.
Except that none of them would have ever expected this encounter to forever change their lives.
Series
- Part 6 of Carra_mele's ShadowVanilla fics
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 29,071
- Chapters:
- 4/10
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 132
- Kudos:
- 274
- Bookmarks:
- 25
- Hits:
- 4,804
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
20 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"Yes— Yes!" Pure Vanilla cried, rolling his hips to meet his cock in the middle. Shadow Milk couldn't last. He slammed down one last time and saw bright stars, his mouth falling open. But just a few simple words were enough to snap him down to reality. "Yeees~♡! Fill me up— Breed me, get me pregnant!!"
Shadow Milk's gentle shifts of the hips, originally easing out the remainder of his orgasm, stopped dead in their tracks.
...What?
Did Pure Vanilla... Want a baby?
AKA: Shadow Milk doesn't know what a breeding kink is and freaks out
Series
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 4,485
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 29
- Kudos:
- 429
- Bookmarks:
- 46
- Hits:
- 4,501
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
31 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Truthless Recluse, a stubborn cookie, feared by many but known by few. Utterly opposed to their beloved Sage of Truth. Enemies, they might appear to be at first glance to those who whispered and gossiped. Little did they know of the odd relationship they held beneath the veil, a long-standing game that danced between the lines of love and hate. A taste of freedom from the burdens they bear.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
31 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
It surfaced in a flurry of whitewash. Without even a second thought, she heaved it over the railing. In a torrent of water and weeds and wiggling scales, the net landed with a wet thump in the middle of the deck. It twisted into itself, a monster clawing away at the insides. Arms aching fiercely, she stumbled away a pace or two, staring slack-jawed at the sheer volume of scales laced behind knots. Not even a blasted spinner shark is that big; it’s almost as if it’s a-
Her hat toppled to the ground, forgotten.
“By the Witches’ garlicky breath-“ Hollyberry swore.
She had caught herself a mermaid.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
26 May 2026
-
The Reason Why You Don't Eat the Neighbours by Etnoe
Fandoms: Don't Eat the Neighbours | Big Teeth Bad Breath
20 Dec 2006
Tags
Summary
Fox and Wolf have gone hunting Rabbit many times - too many! And someone has finally decided to take steps to fix the problem.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 4,099
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 24
- Kudos:
- 173
- Bookmarks:
- 19
- Hits:
- 1,783
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
12 Apr 2026
-
Tags
Summary
“Sorry—” Shamil whispered to him, starting to pet his hair. “—go back to sleep Vally.” He continued to soothe him.
It would have worked too, being sweet talked like this and having his hair played with? Impossible to resist.
But it did occur to Valani…
“Dear you have work.”
---
OR: a little fluffy oneshot of Valani and Shamil from Night Dancer that takes place 6 years in the future after the original story has concluded (includes smut)
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
16 Mar 2026
-
Summary
In which Truthless Recluse is a college student with a particularly irksome professor he can't help but find more than just annoying, and the Sage of Truth is that aforementioned professor who really wants to get into Recluse's head, heart, and pants.
(7/12 + Art)
- Words:
- 65,401
- Works:
- 8
- Bookmarks:
- 42
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
12 Feb 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Truthless Recluse held his gaze quietly, ever so slightly tilting his head to the side.
…
And just like that, Shamil’s heart was caught.
--
OR: Valani works in a coffee shop during the day and a stripper at night to make ends meet. What will happen when he meets a certain, rich, wickedly smart blue haired man?
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 116,560
- Chapters:
- 36/?
- Comments:
- 1,793
- Kudos:
- 3,795
- Bookmarks:
- 298
- Hits:
- 84,857
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
09 Jan 2026
-
Summary
Being baked as a fully grown adult with all of the knowledge in the universe and being expected to bring peace to Earthbread (when a normal cookie wouldn't even know how to walk yet) is undoubtedly traumatizing. As much as he doesn't want to admit it, Shadow Milk wishes that he was given a chance to be a normal kid who was loved unconditionally without the expectations that came along with his Soul Jam. He may not be able to turn back time, but he can find comfort in disguising himself as a child (who he named "Blueberry Cream Cookie") and allowing himself to indulge in his more childish impulses with Pure Vanilla at his side.
- Words:
- 32,024
- Works:
- 4
- Bookmarks:
- 91
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
09 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
So long has the Faerie King Pure Vanilla been plagued by dreams from a voice that wished to drag him to Deceit, to corrupt him from seeing the Truth of this world.
Pure Vanilla wanted nothing more than to take his beloved Voice of Deceit into his arms. Praying for a day that they could be together not through another's help.Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
02 Jan 2026
-
Tags
Summary
The idea of becoming Shadow Milk's literal plaything should have been nothing but abhorrent. Truthless Recluse had already given up so much at the hands of the Beast, did he really need to give up his will as well? Or, if he couldn't find the heart to be offended, he at least should have had the self preservation to not want to be utterly mindless in his grasp.
Except Recluse was just weary enough to deeply crave the sweet escape that Shadow Milk was promising.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
12 Dec 2025
-
Tags
Summary
Viridescent Daydream sighed happily, watching the bluebirds waddle closer for attention, morphos fluttering about, and his prized flora in bloom.
He laid back, arms crossing over his stomach, annoyed chirps in his direction.
Viridescent Daydream winced, forgetting they had been behind him as apologies flew out of his mouth as he picked the poor thing up and warbled, checking them over.
Though strange… he was forgetting things more and more often…
One had nestled in the locks of his hair, pecking at random strands. Another, bigger and lazier, had slumped down in his collar.
Nothing too outside of his normal, with the sun warming his wings perfectly, his animals quieting down, and being swallowed by the long blades of grass, uncaring of the stains it would later leave.
He smiled, body relaxing.
A nap wouldn’t hurt.
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
22 Nov 2025
-
Spawn of The Ancient Beasts by an_undead_gamer_45, PaintinBeyondExpectations
Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)
28 Jun 2026
Tags
Summary
Back when the Virtues were falling and transforming into beats, Shadow Milk found himself plagued with a deep sense of loniness. All his former friends, the beasts, were slipping away from him and their motley crew was falling to pieces.
He couldn't stand idly by and let that happen so he decided the best way to bring them all back together was to introduce a few bundles of baby dough into their lives, making them come together as one big twisted family.
The mixture was prepared and the oven was heated but Shadow Milk never got a chance to bake their sons and daughters thanks to the machinations of Silent Salt and Dark Enchantress Cookie, leaving his plans and his family lost to time.
Until those very same children resurface countless years later, totally unaware of their origins. Fortunately their uncle Shadow Milk, recently freed from the prison of the Silver Tree, is more than happy to arrange a few family reunions!
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 175,297
- Chapters:
- 26/?
- Comments:
- 483
- Kudos:
- 941
- Bookmarks:
- 182
- Hits:
- 38,025
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
09 Nov 2025
-
Tags
Summary
He was still alone.
Good.
Heart thudding in his chest, Truthless Recluse took the time to lean on the tree and lift his foot. He struggled with the zipper on his boot and cried when it got stuck, but he managed to yank his foot free. He put his barefoot back down, shocks of pain raced up his leg.---
Truthless Recluse escapes from The Spire, but he has something The Fount wants.
Series
- Part 2 of Truthless Doll AU
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 313,119
- Chapters:
- 90/92
- Comments:
- 2,366
- Kudos:
- 800
- Bookmarks:
- 77
- Hits:
- 44,390
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
20 Oct 2025
-
Tags
Summary
The Fount of Knowledge stood above mortal needs. Pristine and pure, as perfectly as he was baked.
Yet, the mysterious arrival of a healer, too kind, too close. It sparked something within him. Affection and obsession are entwined in his mind. That most intoxicating poison, his most precious Healer Cookie. Even his most devoted follower can do nothing but join his fall.
Series
- Part 1 of Larkspurs syrup
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
03 Sep 2025
-
Tags
Summary
OR: Truthless is a doll and Shadow send him to spy on the ancients!
✨✨✨
🎭~~🌹~~🎭
“WHAT?!”
Pure Vanilla’s voice, sharp with anger, burst through the door.
Lily’s heart jumped. She’d never heard him angry before. Not like that.
“No... No, no! You said I’d be here for two months!” he snapped. “Now you’re asking me to stay for a year?! It’s hard enough pretending to be happy—but staying here for a whole year?”
Lily’s breath caught.
Staying here instead of going where?
She instinctively cast an invisibility spell and slipped through the door, silent as wind.
Pure Vanilla—or whoever he was now—stood with his back to her, shoulders rigid, hands clenched. He looked... disheveled. Angry. Frustrated.
“I don’t want to be here!” he shouted. “I feel my obedience slipping, and these Cookies... They’re nice! It’s too much. I don’t like it. The mask you told me to wear is becoming realer every day!”
A soft, mocking voice responded.
“Ohhhh, my little Recluse wants to come home?” Shadow Milk crooned through the deceit eye. “Do you miss your master that much?”
Lily’s heart dropped like a stone.
Master?
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
09 Aug 2025
-
Kiss my soul...(I need it please) by StrawberryPillow01
Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)
05 Aug 2025
Tags
Summary
A rather strong sickness has hit Pure Vanilla in the face during his errands in the Vanilla Kingdom. Suddenly becoming the patient in the middle of a thunderstorm, he struggles to keep his mouth shut as fever and the itch in his soul jam overwhelmed the healer who only craves the arms of his nemesis.
Will Shadow Milk come to his aid or use his weakness against him?
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
05 Aug 2025
-
Tags
Summary
[After narrowly escaping the Garden of Delights and defeating its mistress, Hollyberry Cookie returns to her kingdom to the sound of cheers and celebrations. But no amount of berry juice or laughter can silence the haunting memory of the angelic Beast of Sloth who had held her captive in paradise.
Plagued by guilt, longing, and the creeping realization that her kingdom may no longer need her, Hollyberry abandons everything under the cover of night and embarks on a solitary journey back to Beast Yeast. Driven by obsession and desperation, she stumbles once more into the Garden’s ruins.
As Hollyberry’s resolve falters and her heart teeters between duty and desire, old wounds reopen, and the lines between love and captivity blur. In the shadows of a paradise undone, she must confront not only Eternal Sugar’s tender, twisted devotion—but her own.]
or
[Hollyberry Cookie, unable to shake her obsession with Eternal Sugar Cookie, abandons her kingdom and returns alone to the ruined Garden of Delights. Confronting the haunting sweetness of the paradise and the Cookie she thought she had escaped.]
(Smut in Ch 4!)
Bookmarked by CrypticPaw
23 Jul 2025