19 Works by imaginaryprotagonist
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
When a newly human Castiel returns to the bunker after the April incident, Dean decides to shoot his shot, admitting he’s been in love with him for years but never thought an angel could return his feelings. As it turns out, Castiel feels the same way, so Dean decides to give him the sexual experience he should have had for his first time—one where he is worshipped.
In other words, Ezekiel/Gadreel isn’t a great big bag of dicks and Castiel stays in the bunker like he fucking should have in canon!...but with porn.
-
Tags
Summary
Sam’s dying wish was for Dean to go to Lisa and finally live the apple pie life, so of course he was going to try. And he did, for six months, until the burden of his grief and trauma became too much and Lisa finally decided to call it quits. Feeling broken and alone, Dean spirals into a dark place, eventually prompting a distressed Castiel to finally reveal himself, and the fact that he’s been watching him from the shadows.
-
Tags
Summary
When Dean was a teenager, he met Castiel Novak on a family vacation. The pair formed a fast friendship, which came to an abrupt end when Castiel confessed romantic feelings and Dean told him he didn’t feel the same way. It was an act seeped in regret, with Dean realizing he had in fact fallen for the other boy once he had come to terms with his bisexuality. Fourteen years later, a thirty-year-old Dean may have another chance when he runs into Castiel on his train ride home.
-
Dean Winchester is Excited to Tackle Castiel Novak by imaginaryprotagonist
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
09 Feb 2026
Tags
Summary
Castiel Novak is the new starter for the United States under twenty-one rugby union team, competing at the International Youth Rugby Championships in Australia. Dean Winchester is angered by Novak’s selection after an incident during a match back home, and he just has a bad feeling about the guy. It doesn’t take long for Dean to realize that the knots in his stomach aren’t hatred at all—they’re desire.
-
A Christmas Closet by imaginaryprotagonist for hollyblue2
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
15 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
Having a general disdain for the holiday season, Castiel is content to spend the company Christmas party downing a few drinks in the corner with Meg before making a quick exit. That is, until a challenge from Meg drives Castiel to make a move on his secret (or so he thought) crush, Dean Winchester—a move that yields promising results.
-
Tags
Summary
Dean’s entire life has been a string of bad luck: some because he’s suffered the consequences of drug kingpin John Winchester’s terrible decision-making, some because he seems to have inherited the trait. After being attacked in an alley, Dean is saved by a mysterious man in a trench coat. Castiel turns out to be a cop determined to arrest two key players in Chicago's illegal drug game; a corrupt politician, and a murderous drug dealer with a dark connection to Dean. He offers Dean an opportunity to turn his life around, in exchange for helping Cas gain access to these people. Their cover story? Castiel, or rather, 'Jimmy', is Dean’s new boyfriend.
-
Tags
Summary
Jack is distraught when a hopeless Dean meets his demise at the hands of a piece of rebar. As the new God, he knows all. He especially knows that Dean loves Cas as much as Cas loves Dean. So, discarding his commitment to remain hands off, he infiltrates the Empty to save his father, who he knows is the only person who can convince Dean to live again. But, when a sceptical Cas doesn't believe Dean reciprocates his love, Jack decides to show Cas some of the moments—tearing through Purgatory to find him, gazing at him through the window in Rexford, the aftermath of his death at the lake house, and so many more—that prove just how in love with him Dean really is.
-
Tags
Summary
Dean and Cas are best friends and roommates. They’re also in love with each other, and the only people who can’t see that are themselves. Their friends and family can’t take it anymore, conspiring to get them to admit their feelings at Charlie’s annual summer barbecue.
-
If the World Has to End, I'm Glad I Have You by my Side by imaginaryprotagonist
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
11 Jun 2025
Tags
Summary
Relegated as a conspiracy nutjob, John Winchester ignored the naysayers and built an underground bunker in preparation for the spread of a deadly virus he knew was coming. When the first few cases are reported, John flees to California to retrieve Sam, who didn’t believe his dad either, leaving Dean behind to hold down the fort. After months without contact with his family and the world descended into chaos, Dean ends up saving the life of a man trying to break into his home to seek refuge. Castiel is a doctor who has been on the run since witnessing the violent behavior of those infected. The two men form a bond, finding comfort in each other as they hide away from the end of the world.
-
Tags
Summary
When the Winchesters score a break between cases, they decide to let off some steam at a local dive bar, dragging Castiel along with them in the hope he also has some fun after being cooped up in the bunker recovering from Rowena’s attack dog spell. It turns out their chosen dive bar is hosting a karaoke night. Dean doesn’t waste any time, racing to the microphone. When Dean sings, his focus seems to be on Castiel, so the angel asks a drunken Sam to help him deduce the meaning of the songs. It goes… poorly.
-
Oops, I Slipped and Called You Daddy Again by imaginaryprotagonist
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
17 May 2025
Tags
Summary
After his roommate Dean throws a temper tantrum, Cas decides to get back at him by calling him Daddy in a Starbucks. Things escalate.
-
Tags
Summary
When God left, the angels fell to Earth and asserted their rule over humans. Their control was seemingly unquestioned until a rebel by the name of Dean Winchester mobilized an anarchist group to overthrow the system. Just as they were beginning to make progress, Dean is captured and imprisoned in a mysterious room that appears to be floating in space, which is guarded by a low-level angel called Castiel.
-
Tags
Summary
While staying at a hotel for a work conference, Dean opens what he thinks is the closet door but turns out to be an adjoining room that has been accidentally left unlocked. He is greeted by the most attractive man he has ever seen in nothing but a towel. The man, Cas, seems incredibly amused, while Dean has zero chill about the situation. After the embarrassing encounter, Dean discovers Cas is the moderator of a panel he is speaking on.
-
Tags
Summary
After getting crafty and creating a Castiel tree topper, Dean gleefully darts around the bunker to stick the miniature angel on assorted phallic-shaped objects (despite real-size Cas and Sam's exasperation). Then, Cas turns the tables on Dean when he catches him and the ornament in a... compromising position.
-
Tags
Summary
After the events in Tombstone, the pulse of energy that Jack sends out to knock over Dean, Sam, and Castiel before he disappears unintentionally erases more than a decade of Dean’s memory. Decidedly sick of the pining and eye-fucking he has been privy to, Sam impulsively uses the situation to his advantage. As they wait for Castiel to return from searching for Jack, Sam fills Dean in on the life he has forgotten, including the little white lie that Dean and Castiel are in a relationship.
-
Tags
Summary
After meeting and falling for each other fast at a New Year’s Eve party, Cas reveals to Dean he will be away for work and uncontactable for a year. They agree to meet up at the same party the following year so they can be together. But Cas is running late.
-
Tags
Summary
Dean uses mistletoe as an excuse to make out with Castiel while maintaining to Sam that it’s just Christmas dudes being Christmas bros.
Series
- Part 1 of Strategic Mistletoe Usage
-
Tags
Summary
The French Mistake but Dean realizes the network has tried to censor his bisexuality and he is PISSED!
Based on a Tumblr prompt I posted ages ago and finally decided to take a stab at.
-
The Art of Manipulating an Angel and a Hunter by imaginaryprotagonist
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
09 Aug 2024
Tags
Summary
Crowley knows Dean and Castiel are hot for each other. He also knows they're morons and they're not going to do anything about it. At least, not without a little (or a big) nudge. Convincing both the angel and the hunter that he is seducing the other one, Crowley takes great pleasure in driving them both mad with jealousy to see which one cracks first.
Inspired by a Tumblr prompt by @thefableddestiel (https://tinyurl.com/2un856et)