justtheaveragefangirl
Fandoms
- Glee (TV 2009) (10)
- Supernatural (TV 2005) (7)
- Hadestown - Mitchell (5)
- Batman - All Media Types (5)
- Batman (Comics) (4)
Recent works
-
Tags
Summary
It’s the annual paladin reunion and Keith and Lance finally decide to act on their feelings
-
There Are Monsters That Live In Your Head by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandoms: Supernatural (TV 2005)
08 Jun 2024
Tags
Summary
Dean's always known there was this empty pit inside of him where a person was supposed to be. He didn't need Famine to tell him about it. He knows he's broken.
Cas begs to differ
-
Post 5x14 Dean character study
-
Heaven is Not Fit to House a Love Like You and I by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandoms: Good Omens - Neil Gaiman & Terry Pratchett, Good Omens (TV)
31 Aug 2023
Tags
Summary
And after it all starts to go wrong, Aziraphale finds himself at the bookshop
-
Tied Together With A Smile by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandoms: Batman (Comics), Batman - All Media Types
15 Nov 2022
Tags
Summary
Dick gets attacked.
The entire family is in shock.
Except Jason. Jason is ready to do what needs to be done.
-
Tags
Summary
After many, many years of living peacefully in Heaven, Dean gets turned upside down when a random hunter barges into his house while being chased by angels. Dean realizes that everything is not what it seams.
Series
Recent series
-
Supernatural Fics I Wrote Because I Was Personally Victimized By The Ending by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandom Supernatural, Supernatural (TV 2005)
25 Aug 2022
Summary
What the tin says
- Words:
- 17,857
- Works:
- 3
-
Lifelong Friends by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandom Red White & Royal Blue - Casey McQuiston
25 Mar 2021
Summary
AU where Alex and Henry grew up together after the families met at a Buckingham Christmas banquet.
Canon-verse (Cakegate and the Waterloo letters did, in fact, happen)
Not necessarily in chronological order
- Words:
- 5,893
- Works:
- 3
- Bookmarks:
- 27
-
Extending The Family by justtheaveragefangirl
Fandom Arrow (TV 2012), Arrow-Verse - Fandom, Batman (Comics), Batman - All Media Types, Batwoman (TV 2019)
22 Oct 2021
Summary
The introduction of the Batfamily into the arrowverse via Batwoman
Follows canon through season 2 (I’ll be upfront, the only arrowverse shows I’ve followed since 2018 are Legends and Batwoman so it might not be entirely canonically accurate. Let’s just pretend I’m doing it on purpose for narrative flow. Thank you)
- Words:
- 7,965
- Works:
- 3
- Bookmarks:
- 19
-
- Words:
- 1,035
- Works:
- 2
-
Summary
Inspired by the line "Maybe it will turn out this time" from Road To Hell.
Some alternate endings about what could have happened to Orpheus and Eurydice.
Some sad, some happy, but that's what life is.- Words:
- 1,838
- Works:
- 5
- Bookmarks:
- 6
Recent bookmarks
-
Get you under pink skies by whenyoureplayingsolitaire
Fandoms: Hunger Games Trilogy - Suzanne Collins, Hunger Games Series - All Media Types
20 Apr 2026
Tags
Summary
Dreams and nightmares. Hallucinations and memories. Fantasies and self-flagellations. In the middle of the night, these things can be so hard to tell apart. Good thing he's got this one on tape.
Written for Everlark Week 2026 on Tumblr (Day 1: you love me. real or not real?)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 5,801
- Chapters:
- 1/1
- Collections:
- 1
- Comments:
- 25
- Kudos:
- 159
- Bookmarks:
- 29
- Hits:
- 1,893
Bookmarked by justtheaveragefangirl
21 Jul 2026
-
Nothing Looks The Same In The Light by Pacific_Restless_Sleeper
Fandoms: Stranger Things (TV 2016)
04 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
With all the supernatural, inter-dimensional terrors, it's sometimes easy to forget the mundane, real world horrors that plague the world.
Steve goes missing shortly after his parents unexpectedly arrive back home. Dustin rallies what remains of the Party after half their team has left for California to try and get him back. Except this time it’s not the Upside Down, just good old fashioned human prejudice. To spring Steve from the conversion therapy camp his parents sent him to, the Party turns to a new, tentative ally who has some experience in criminal acts, general misbehaviour, and maybe even the very place Steve’s been sent to: Eddie Munson.
Bookmarked by justtheaveragefangirl
04 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
"Then, his mind recalled the events of the day before, the beating he’d endured, the death he’d came close to and the near-zero impacts it all had had on his body. If it had taken place mere hours ago, severe lesions and wounds should have made moving in the slightest an unbearable chore. Yet, despite his sore arms and legs, he felt in pretty good health.
Jack let himself sink down on the couch, his right hand going back and forth through his mustache hair. Had he really traveled back in time? The thought made his hair stand on end. Yet, he saw no other explanation for whatever was happening, and the more he thought about it, the more any other explanation that might have bloomed into his mind instantly withered."
Or,
Jack is beaten up and left to drown in his own blood. The next day, he wakes up mostly fine and everything is oddly familiar. Jack Twist is forced to live the day of his death over and over again. Will he manage to put a stop to it?
Bookmarked by justtheaveragefangirl
28 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Under his breath, Eddie giggles. He hears the noise crest behind them as they walk, like a cloud of angry bees after their hive has been shaken up. It’s a fact, now, that Eddie Munson, resident freak drug-dealing alpha, is very publicly hanging around newly presented omega Steve Harrington. Alpha and omega, the perfect cookie-cutter combo the normies love to call a perfect match.
“Munson,” Harrington mutters, barely moving his lips. “What the fuck do you think you are doing?”
Or: Eddie is the king of bad ideas. Fake-courting Steve Harrington for the hell of it might take the crown.
(Updates weekly!)
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 54,503
- Chapters:
- 10/10
- Comments:
- 346
- Kudos:
- 996
- Bookmarks:
- 227
- Hits:
- 14,774
Bookmarked by justtheaveragefangirl
28 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
First impressions are often wrong. Steve’s first impression of Eddie was that he was a crass older alpha with too many tattoos to ever possibly be gainfully employed. Eddie’s first impression of Steve was that he was a young uptight omega who needed to get the pretentiousness fucked right out of him.
Their first date was an absolute disaster, but the one night of passion they spent together afterwards was a decent consolation prize… At least until the pregnancy test shows up positive a few weeks later.
-or-
Two people who hate each other decide to coparent a baby bump until they inevitably fall in love.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 37,500
- Chapters:
- 4/4
- Collections:
- 3
- Comments:
- 166
- Kudos:
- 1,084
- Bookmarks:
- 206
- Hits:
- 14,148
Bookmarked by justtheaveragefangirl
27 Jun 2026