17 Bookmarks by Colorful_throwup
List of Bookmarks
-
Tags
Summary
You were obsessed with creepypastas as a kid. You've quickly grown out of that phase, but still kept all your old merch and sketchbooks. You discover them again one random day in spring, remembering all the fun you used to have. You find a sketchbook with strange drawings inside it, and decide to keep it out of the box. Little did you know that it would change your life.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
09 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
You are the lowest of the low internet haters. You find a guy posting and commenting under edgy videos and decide to be his biggest hater.
Yeah turns out the person you’re threatening is a killer! He’s at your house.
~~~~~~~
Will I continue this? I don’t know. Basically you threaten ticci Toby online and he likes it an is now at your house
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
05 Jul 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Two years and twenty-one days.
That’s how long you have been in service to the Operator. As one of his chosen, you struggle with the loss of the life you had before. All your dreams and hopes, gone to this endless service, with too many bad decisions buried in your past to ever go back. It’s all your fault, really. Playing both sides of life, supernatural and mundane, never expecting you’d have to pay the piper. Who knew bringing a lover back from the dead would have consequences?
Now you have too many problems, and too much power, to ever be free. Witch or demon (you don’t really know what you are), with your memories all jumbled in that thick slop you call a brain. And one head proxy is both the bane of your existence and the object of all your desires.
Not that you can admit that. Especially when Tobias seems to know you better than you know yourself.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
22 Jun 2026
-
I tried to be good, am I no good? (Ticci Toby x male reader) by rosaryyonthenightstand
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
04 Apr 2026
Tags
Summary
A pastors son, you, has had a recent run-in with some.. cryptic looking guy, at your local church where your father attends and works at. Ever since that, he's started to make his way into your life, despite your own protests.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
20 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Cops and robbers. Its all harmless play. Guns made of sticks and hideouts in the bushes. The suburbs are a quaint place to grow with your best friend. Its not serious. Its just fake violence and a little make believe. Toby is just a bit busy. He's always sick but mom says he'll be fine.
Cops and robbers once more but now you're the cop, now and the stakes are real. When you grow up to be the detective your father always hoped you'd be, you're given a case on a series of murders. One strangely familiar to an old cold case of a long gone friend that sits in your desk. And this time its multiplayer.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
20 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
[Originally published on Quotev under my account /catnips, deleted + reworked because I hated it lolz] You are an introverted librarian from a small town surrounded by beautiful woodlands. You take careful note of the comings and goings, and find yourself yearning for human connection--for someone as interested in keeping a watchful eye on you as you do for them. In the midst of a humdrum work day, your routine is interrupted by a mysteriously dressed stranger.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
15 Jun 2026
-
Don’t close the window by deepbluesea (ItsThyme), ItsThyme
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
04 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
You were saved by strange men in a brutally violent way, in a very unlucky night. One of them takes quite the interest in you.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
12 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
After moving alone into a late grandfather’s isolated cabin deep within the forest, far away from the city and completely disconnected from society, what first seems like a peaceful but lonely life slowly begins to turn unsettling after a series of paranormal events. As strange occurrences intensify around the cabin, the feeling of being watched becomes impossible to ignore, and the forest surrounding the house no longer feels empty. Little by little, an unknown presence begins drawing closer from the darkness.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
08 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Y/N and Toby are both hiding something; they hate each other. But in some ways, they're similar. Eventually, their bond becomes something more.
If you're looking for a long read of a complex Y/N X Toby fanfic. You've come to the right place! This is an ongoing fanfic, with more to come. Tags will be updated accordingly. Not only are these my little fantasies of Toby, but this is also a fic to practice my writing :3
⋆ . ˚ ⦻ ｡ 𖦹 ° ‧
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
05 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
ORIGINALLY POSTED ON WATTPAD: @kraffmacaronii,
https://www.wattpad.com/story/408292733-on-line-creepypasta-fic
Texting fic: lowercase intended
Multiple parts will be posted at once.
NO AI WAS USED IN ANY OF THIS"You were desperate enough to hire a killer"
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
05 Jun 2026
-
Sink your teeth in by breathingstarsnotair
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
25 Jun 2026
Tags
Summary
As the daughter of a powerful cult leader who works for the Operator, you are accustomed to living in a cage of ancient decay and the dark shadow of the forest. You are used to the cloying scent of rot, the silent judgment of cultists, and the heavy weight of the covenant. What you aren't used to is being babysat–least of all by a wannabe bodyguard who secretly hates you.
Toby is a Proxy–a twitching, volatile, and arrogant killer who views your family’s ministry as a boring administrative chore and you as a spoiled brat. In the public eye, he is the perfectly polite, bowing guardian. Behind closed doors, he is an arrogant, disrespectful parasite; a nightmare who delights in pushing your buttons and challenging your authority.
But when, one night, the two of you get into a violent argument–and your hands take pleasure in hurting him–he seems to enjoy it himself more than he should. It is therefore hardly surprising that he attempts to provoke such a situation again–solely to coax you out of your shell.
Yet, you hate him. That’s why, for the life of you, you cannot fathom why–despite your contempt–you let him do things to you that feel better than they have any right to…
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
04 Jun 2026
-
Unrequited (Yandere! Ticci Toby x Reader) by vranda18
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos
04 Jan 2024
Tags
Summary
After working so hard to rebuild a life for yourself, you caught the eye of the last person you'd want. How could one awkward encounter at a gas station change so much?
All you wanted was to move forward, finally break a never ending cycle in your life, but he wanted to drag you down with him.
This is technically “Yandere'' but I’m trying to make this as realistic as possible. Written in both the Reader and Toby’s perspective - switching each chapter. First time writing anything in over 7 years so I'm very rusty.
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 30,242
- Chapters:
- 10/?
- Comments:
- 201
- Kudos:
- 1,038
- Bookmarks:
- 108
- Hits:
- 21,451
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
02 Jun 2026
-
Tags
Summary
ticci toby x reader short story
- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 58,072
- Chapters:
- 16/16
- Comments:
- 192
- Kudos:
- 2,467
- Bookmarks:
- 275
- Hits:
- 49,117
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
31 May 2026
-
In the Spaces Between (Ticci Toby x male!reader) by robynlovyn
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
05 Mar 2026
Tags
Summary
Toby's tics are worse tonight. Something about the last mission, something about the way you almost didn't come back. You're the only person who knows how to calm him down—the only person he lets close enough to try. In the quiet of your shared room, vulnerability turns into something else entirely.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
31 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Average Ticci Toby x Reader (Y/N).
You used to bully toby, so you're basically cannon.I DO NOT USE AI IN MY WORKS, BUT I DO USE SEMI COLONS AND DASHES ;)
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
31 May 2026
-
Tags
Summary
Ticci toby x Reader but its a slowburn. Toby lives in a cabin in the woods and terrorises the local townspeople until SOMEONE (you) winds up in his path, and a storm is about to hit.
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
29 May 2026
-
Chew Me Up And Spit Me Out by Beepboop0o0
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Slender Man Mythos
15 Jul 2026
Tags
Summary
Loosely follows the beginning of the Jennifer's Body(2009) movie. this is also cross posted on my Tumblr :) @b33bb00p
You snatch him by the neck with a single fist, holding him in place as you stand up off the ground. He was kneeling before you, one of his hands gripped your own and you leant down and pulled him close, face to face once more. You could smell the sweet tang of fear bubbling under his skin, not nearly enough for your taste, but you drag your nose along his neck basking in the aroma. He lets out a shaky breath.
Growling, you look him in the eyes.
“I will eat your fucking soul”
Bookmarked by Colorful_throwup
29 May 2026