Comment on Rip Tide

  1. Pan! Sarah Jacobs

    Thank you so much. I have had a truly awful day today, so it was such a blessing to find this comment when I finally had a moment of calm. I had never tried writing Lucy and Caspian as a pair before, though I have always loved the thought of them, and I found that I really loved writing both of these stories. I have the beginnings of a third, though I think it will take longer to complete.

    I deeply appreciate your thoughts about how struggles with faith come across in these stories - I am glad that it all was moving for you! In "Rip Tide," especially, I wanted to think about Lucy's crisis of faith, and what it would mean for her (and for her siblings) if something so terrible happened that it really made her question her faith in Aslan. And there is a little of that at the end of "Mortal Time," too, when she is angry at him for how much she and her siblings have had to bear. I absolve Aslan of some of it, but not all, I admit - I think it would be very easy for Him to forget how hard it is to be mortal. He has eternity, after all, and the lives of mortals are so short, and He has other worlds besides Earth to watch over. But it really seemed to me that losing Caspian and Rilian would be Lucy's breaking point, particularly if she felt initially that Aslan could have prevented it, that she was being put through this kind of pain on purpose. As you say, her faith does not spare her pain, and even Lucy can still struggle with her faith and be mad at Aslan. I wanted to show that even Lucy is not perfect in her faith, that she is still human despite her great love for Aslan, and so she still struggles.

    I loved watching Ben Barnes in Shadow and Bone! I freely admit that he was some of my inspiration for this Caspian. :) And I am very happy to have you use my story as a prequel if you like - what a lovely compliment! I think the central idea for your story is wonderful - the Darkling would certainly be very different if he had Caspian's heart and conscience, and his relationship with Alina very different too. :) I am sure I will greatly enjoy your story, if and when you post it! Please let me know! :)

    Comment Actions
    1. Thank you for your reply. And your story also brightened my day since I am stuck writing very important paper and this fic was my power up 😉
      And this is why I I loved it so much 💕 Because her struggle is painted beautifuly. And Susan! One letter but this one. Her explanation seems so much more in character that Lewis gave us. I understand why he did that, since it's mainly for children but from audult's perspective it may seem that it was too little.
      And I forgot to write that I like your portrayal of Eustace. I am fond of this character and it is nice to see how already adventures in Narnia changed him in this little moments. I can't wait for more of him. And I am curious if now when he knows already who he is looking for he will have more interactions with Caspian. Bacuse Lewis really deprived us from this and owww... (and I admit that Ben and Will Poulter's friendship may could my judgement but whatever 😅 )
      Thank you for agreeing 😁 I will definitely notify you when my story will come out. It just may take a while. English isn't my native language so... 😅
      And I can't wait for your next works in this series. Especially some married life fluff (and the wedding 😉). But I am sure that everything will be dear to my heart like this two fragments already are.

      Comment Actions
      1. Pan! Sarah Jacobs

        Oh, my goodness! I hope your very important paper is going well, or maybe did go well if you have already finished it. 😊

        I absolutely agree with you about Susan - while it makes sense that Lewis would leave out most details, since he was writing for children, it is so unsatisfying as an adult reader! I wanted to show that Susan is still a thinking person, with real and serious disagreements with Aslan and therefore with her siblings, but it doesn't mean she does not love them.

        Thank you for the comment about Eustace! I really enjoyed writing him in "Rip Tide," especially, and I also hope that he will have more direct interaction with Caspian when he goes back to Narnia, since he knows in advance that he is looking for Rilian. It will be interesting to see if Jill's journey is different, too!

        I very much look forward to your story, whenever you are able to write it. 😊 And in the meantime, I will keep working on my own story - which, as you guessed, is Lucy and Caspian's return to Narnia, their wedding, and figuring out how to rule together. I hope you will enjoy it when I manage to get it finished! Thank you for such kind comments - it makes me very happy that you liked this so much. 💗💗💗

        Comment Actions